TL;DR
Aider is an open-source CLI tool where you control your API keys and data flow directly to AI providers. Cursor is a closed-source IDE that routes requests through their servers with optional Privacy Mode. Aider gives you more control and transparency, while Cursor provides a polished experience with additional features. Both send code to cloud AI providers for processing.
Aider and Cursor represent different philosophies in AI coding tools. Aider is a command-line tool that works with your existing editor and gives you direct control over AI provider connections. Cursor is a VS Code fork with integrated AI features and a managed service layer. This comparison examines their security and privacy implications.
Platform Overview
What Is Aider?
Aider is an open-source AI pair programming tool that runs in your terminal. It connects directly to AI providers (OpenAI, Anthropic, etc.) using your own API keys. Aider reads your codebase, understands git history, and makes edits directly to files. Being open source, you can audit exactly what it does with your code.
What Is Cursor?
Cursor is a closed-source code editor forked from VS Code with deep AI integration. It provides code completion, chat, and multi-file editing features. Cursor has its own backend service that handles API routing, user management, and additional features like codebase indexing. Privacy Mode prevents code storage on Cursor servers.
Security Feature Comparison
| Security Feature | Aider | Cursor |
|---|---|---|
| Open Source | Yes (Apache 2.0) | No |
| API Key Control | Your keys, direct connection | Cursor-managed or BYOK |
| Middle Layer | None | Cursor servers |
| Privacy Mode | Inherent (no intermediary) | Optional setting |
| Codebase Indexing | Local only | Can be cloud-synced |
| Auditability | Full source available | Limited to policies |
| Local Models | Supported (Ollama, etc.) | Not supported |
| Enterprise Features | DIY | Business tier |
Data Flow Transparency
Aider's Direct Connection
Aider connects directly from your machine to AI providers. When you use Aider with OpenAI, your code goes straight to OpenAI's API. There's no intermediate service layer collecting telemetry or routing requests. You can verify this by reading the source code or monitoring network traffic. The privacy picture is simple: your machine to AI provider.
Aider transparency benefits:
- Open source code you can audit
- Direct API connections with no intermediary
- Your API keys stay on your machine
- No account or telemetry required
Cursor's Service Layer
Cursor routes requests through their backend services, even when using your own API keys. This enables features like usage tracking, team management, and codebase indexing. With Privacy Mode enabled, Cursor commits to not storing your code, but requests still flow through their infrastructure. You're trusting Cursor's policies rather than verifying through code.
Cursor service layer considerations:
- Requests route through Cursor servers
- Privacy Mode prevents storage but not transit
- Features like indexing may sync data
- Can't independently verify behavior
Local Model Support
Aider with Local Models
Aider supports local models through Ollama, LM Studio, and other local inference servers. This means you can use AI coding assistance without any data leaving your machine. The tradeoff is that local models are typically less capable than cloud models, but for sensitive codebases, complete local processing eliminates cloud privacy concerns entirely.
Cursor's Cloud Requirement
Cursor requires cloud AI providers and doesn't support local model deployment. All AI processing happens through external services. If keeping code completely on-premise is a requirement, Cursor isn't an option. This architectural choice enables Cursor's advanced features but limits privacy-maximum scenarios.
Choose Aider When: You want maximum transparency and control over your AI coding workflow. Aider's open source nature and direct API connections provide verifiable privacy. Best for security-conscious developers, those working with sensitive code, or organizations that need to audit their tooling. Also ideal if you want local model support.
Choose Cursor When: You want a polished, integrated experience and trust Cursor's privacy commitments. Cursor's features like intelligent autocomplete and codebase chat provide a smoother workflow. Best for teams that prioritize user experience and are comfortable with managed service security guarantees.
API Key Management
Aider's Approach
Aider reads API keys from environment variables or config files on your machine. Keys never leave your system except when making API calls. You manage key rotation, access control, and billing directly with AI providers. This direct relationship gives you full control but requires more setup and management.
Cursor's Approach
Cursor can use their managed API access (included in subscription) or your own API keys. Even with BYOK (bring your own key), keys are used by Cursor's service to make API calls on your behalf. This managed approach simplifies setup but means entrusting Cursor with your API credentials.
Git Integration Security
Aider's Git Awareness
Aider is deeply integrated with git, automatically committing changes with descriptive messages. It reads git history to understand your codebase. All git operations happen locally with no data sent externally (beyond what goes to AI for code generation). The git integration is transparent and auditable.
Cursor's Git Features
Cursor provides git integration through VS Code's built-in features. Git operations are local, but Cursor's AI features that analyze your codebase may process git history as context for suggestions. With Privacy Mode, this context isn't stored, but it's still processed through Cursor's services.
Best Practices
- Use Aider with local models for maximum privacy on sensitive code
- Enable Cursor Privacy Mode for any commercial work
- Configure .aiderignore or .cursorignore to exclude sensitive files
- Audit Aider's source code for high-security environments
- Use separate API keys for coding tools vs production systems
- Review AI-generated code regardless of tool choice
Can I use Aider without sending code to the cloud?
Yes, Aider supports local models through Ollama and similar tools. With a local model, your code never leaves your machine. This provides maximum privacy at the cost of reduced AI capability compared to cloud models.
Does Cursor store my code even with Privacy Mode?
Cursor's Privacy Mode prevents code storage on their servers, but code still transits through their infrastructure to reach AI providers. You're trusting their commitment rather than architectural guarantees like Aider's direct connection.
Which tool is better for enterprise compliance?
Aider's transparency and local model support make compliance documentation straightforward since you control the entire data flow. Cursor Business offers enterprise features but requires trusting their compliance claims. The choice depends on your organization's risk tolerance.
Can I verify what Aider sends to AI providers?
Yes, Aider is open source and you can read exactly what code it sends to APIs. You can also run it with verbose logging or inspect network traffic. This auditability is a significant security advantage over closed-source alternatives.
Validate AI-Generated Code
CheckYourVibe scans code from Aider, Cursor, and other AI tools for security vulnerabilities.
Try CheckYourVibe Free