TL;DR
Tabnine offers local model deployment and self-hosted options that keep code on your machine, while Copilot requires cloud processing through Microsoft servers. For maximum privacy, Tabnine's on-premise enterprise solution or local-only mode wins. For pure capability with reasonable privacy controls, Copilot Business tier provides no-training guarantees while delivering stronger suggestions.
GitHub Copilot and Tabnine represent different philosophies in AI-assisted coding. Copilot emphasizes powerful cloud-based models, while Tabnine pioneered local AI completion and continues to offer self-hosted deployment. This comparison examines their security and privacy implications for developers who care about where their code goes.
Platform Overview
What Is GitHub Copilot?
GitHub Copilot is Microsoft's AI coding assistant, built on OpenAI models and trained on public code. It provides inline completions, chat-based assistance, and multi-file editing capabilities. All processing happens on Microsoft Azure servers, with various tiers offering different privacy guarantees. It's the most widely adopted AI coding tool.
What Is Tabnine?
Tabnine is an AI code completion tool that predates Copilot and offers unique deployment flexibility. You can use Tabnine with cloud models, local models running on your machine, or fully self-hosted enterprise deployment. This makes Tabnine particularly attractive for security-conscious organizations that can't send code to external servers.
Security Feature Comparison
| Security Feature | GitHub Copilot | Tabnine |
|---|---|---|
| Local Processing | Not available | Yes, with local models |
| Self-Hosted Option | Not available | Enterprise tier |
| Cloud Processing | Required | Optional (Pro/Enterprise) |
| Training Opt-Out | Business/Enterprise tiers | All paid tiers |
| SOC 2 Compliance | Type II certified | Type II certified |
| Air-Gapped Deployment | Not possible | Enterprise option |
| Private Model Training | Not available | Enterprise feature |
| Code Never Leaves Network | No | Yes (local/self-hosted) |
Local vs Cloud Processing
Tabnine's Local Model
Tabnine's most distinctive feature is its local model option. A smaller AI model runs directly on your machine, processing code completions without any network requests. This means your code never leaves your computer. The local model is less capable than cloud options but provides maximum privacy for sensitive codebases.
Local mode limitations include:
- Smaller model means less sophisticated suggestions
- No codebase-wide context understanding
- Requires local compute resources
- Missing advanced features like chat
Copilot's Cloud Architecture
GitHub Copilot processes all requests through Microsoft Azure. Your code context is sent to cloud servers where large language models generate completions. There's no offline mode or local processing option. This architecture enables Copilot's powerful suggestions but means code always travels to external servers.
Enterprise Deployment Options
Tabnine Enterprise
Tabnine Enterprise can be deployed entirely within your infrastructure. The AI models run on your servers, connected to your codebase, with no external data transmission. Organizations can even train custom models on their private code, creating AI assistants that understand company-specific patterns without exposing code externally.
Enterprise features include:
- On-premise or VPC deployment
- Custom model training on your code
- Air-gapped network support
- Integration with internal code repositories
Copilot Enterprise
GitHub Copilot Enterprise provides organizational controls but not self-hosted deployment. It offers SAML SSO, audit logging, policy controls, and content exclusions. Copilot can index your GitHub repositories for context, but processing still happens on Microsoft infrastructure. It's enterprise-friendly but not air-gap compatible.
Choose Copilot When: You want the most capable AI suggestions and your security requirements allow cloud processing. Copilot Business tier provides strong privacy guarantees (no training on your code) while delivering superior code generation quality. Best for organizations comfortable with cloud processing under Microsoft's security practices.
Choose Tabnine When: Your code can't leave your network, or you're in a regulated industry requiring on-premise AI. Tabnine's local and self-hosted options provide privacy that Copilot can't match. Best for defense contractors, financial institutions, healthcare, or any organization with strict data residency requirements.
Training Data and IP Concerns
Copilot's Training Background
Copilot was trained on public GitHub repositories, which sparked legal debates about code licensing. The tool has faced lawsuits regarding use of copyleft-licensed code in training. Copilot includes duplicate detection to flag suggestions matching public code, but the underlying IP questions remain unsettled.
Tabnine's Training Approach
Tabnine trains on permissively licensed open source code only, avoiding copyleft licenses that might create legal complications. Enterprise customers can train models exclusively on their own code, creating a clean IP chain. This approach reduces legal risk compared to tools trained on all public code regardless of license.
Privacy in Practice
What Gets Sent to Servers
When using cloud features, both tools send code context around your cursor to their servers. This includes surrounding code, file contents, and sometimes related files. Copilot sends this to Microsoft/OpenAI infrastructure. Tabnine's cloud mode sends to Tabnine servers, or you can eliminate external transmission entirely with local/self-hosted options.
Sensitive Code Handling
For files containing secrets, API keys, or proprietary algorithms, consider your approach carefully. Copilot lets you exclude specific repositories from processing. Tabnine's local mode ensures sensitive code never leaves your machine. Neither tool should process files with hardcoded secrets, regardless of deployment model.
Best Practices
- Use Tabnine local mode for air-gapped or highly sensitive projects
- Enable Copilot Business tier guarantees for commercial code
- Never include secrets in code that AI tools process
- Consider Tabnine Enterprise for regulated industries
- Review suggestions before accepting, especially for security-critical code
- Document your organization's AI tool policies and deployment choices
Does Tabnine's local model work offline?
Yes, Tabnine's local model works completely offline after initial installation. The AI model runs on your machine without any network connectivity required. This is ideal for air-gapped development environments or situations where you can't trust network security.
How does Tabnine local compare to Copilot in quality?
Copilot's cloud models are generally more capable than Tabnine's local model due to the size difference. However, Tabnine's cloud and enterprise options are competitive. The tradeoff is privacy versus suggestion quality when comparing local Tabnine to cloud Copilot.
Can Copilot work without internet access?
No, Copilot requires internet connectivity for all features. There's no offline or local processing mode. If network access is restricted or you're working in an air-gapped environment, Copilot isn't an option.
Is Tabnine Enterprise worth the cost for security?
For organizations that can't allow code to leave their network, Tabnine Enterprise is one of the few options that provides capable AI assistance with complete data control. The cost is justified when regulatory or security requirements mandate on-premise deployment.
Secure Your AI-Generated Code
CheckYourVibe scans code from Copilot, Tabnine, and other AI tools for security vulnerabilities.
Try CheckYourVibe Free