TL;DR
Cyber insurance costs startups $1,000-5,000 annually for $1M coverage, but premiums can double or triple with poor security practices. Insurers now require MFA, endpoint protection, and regular backups before issuing policies. Missing security controls means higher premiums, coverage exclusions, or outright denial. One security incident can raise your premiums 100-300% at renewal.
50-100% Premium increase after a cyber incident claim Source: Coalition Cyber Insurance Report 2024
How Cyber Insurance Pricing Works
Cyber insurance premiums are calculated based on your risk profile. Insurers evaluate your industry, revenue, data sensitivity, and security practices. Unlike traditional insurance where pricing is relatively standardized, cyber premiums vary dramatically based on your specific security posture.
Base premium factors include:
| Factor | Impact on Premium | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Industry | +50-200% | Healthcare and finance pay more |
| Annual Revenue | Base multiplier | Higher revenue means higher coverage needs |
| Data Sensitivity | +25-100% | PII, payment data, health records |
| Security Controls | -20% to +100% | Strong security lowers premiums |
| Claims History | +50-300% | Prior incidents raise future costs |
What Insurers Require in 2026
The cyber insurance market has hardened significantly. Insurers now require specific security controls before issuing policies. Missing these requirements can result in denial, exclusions, or significantly higher premiums.
Must-Have Security Controls
- Multi-factor authentication (MFA): Required for email, VPN, and admin accounts. This is non-negotiable for most insurers.
- Endpoint detection and response (EDR): Basic antivirus is no longer sufficient. Insurers want active threat detection.
- Email security: Phishing protection, DMARC/DKIM/SPF configuration, and employee training.
- Backup systems: Regular backups stored offline or in separate cloud accounts, tested for restoration.
- Incident response plan: Documented procedures for detecting and responding to security incidents.
- Vulnerability management: Regular scanning and patching of systems and applications.
Coverage trap: If you claim to have MFA enabled on your application but do not, your claim may be denied for material misrepresentation. Insurers verify claims during incident investigations.
Premium Cost by Startup Stage
How Poor Security Raises Your Premiums
Security gaps directly translate to higher costs. Here is what specific deficiencies add to your premium:
| Missing Control | Premium Impact | Likely Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| No MFA on email | +50-100% or denial | Many insurers will not quote |
| No backup system | +30-50% | Ransomware exclusion possible |
| No EDR solution | +25-40% | Higher deductibles |
| No employee training | +20-30% | Social engineering exclusion |
| No vulnerability scanning | +15-25% | Limited coverage scope |
The Post-Incident Premium Shock
If you file a cyber insurance claim, expect renewal premiums to increase significantly. A single ransomware incident can increase your premiums 100-300% or result in non-renewal.
Real scenario: A 20-person startup paid $2,500 annually for cyber insurance. After a ransomware attack that cost $150,000 (covered by insurance), their renewal quote came in at $12,000 with a $50,000 deductible, up from $5,000.
How to Lower Your Premiums
Document Your Security Posture
Create documentation of your security controls before applying. This includes MFA configuration, backup schedules, security training records, and vulnerability scan reports. Organized documentation can reduce premiums 10-20%.
Get Security Certifications
SOC 2 Type II certification can reduce premiums 15-25%. ISO 27001 certification has similar effects. While expensive to obtain, the premium savings compound annually.
Use Approved Security Tools
Some insurers offer premium discounts for using specific security vendors. Coalition, for example, offers free security tools to policyholders. Using approved tools can save 5-15%.
Regular Security Assessments
Annual penetration testing and regular vulnerability assessments demonstrate proactive security. Insurers view this favorably and may offer 10-15% discounts.
ROI calculation: Spending $3,000 on security improvements that reduce your $4,000 premium by 25% saves $1,000 annually. Over 3 years, you save $3,000 while also being more secure.
Coverage Exclusions to Watch For
Even with insurance, certain scenarios may not be covered:
- Known vulnerabilities: Incidents caused by unpatched vulnerabilities you knew about
- Infrastructure failures: Cloud provider outages typically excluded
- War and terrorism: Nation-state attacks may be excluded
- Intentional acts: Employee sabotage or insider threats
- Regulatory fines: Some policies exclude government penalties
- Reputational harm: Long-term brand damage often excluded
How much does cyber insurance cost for startups?
Cyber insurance for startups typically costs $1,000 to $5,000 annually for $1M in coverage. Premiums vary based on industry, revenue, data sensitivity, and security practices. Startups handling financial or health data pay higher premiums.
What security requirements do cyber insurers check?
Common requirements include multi-factor authentication (MFA), endpoint protection, regular backups, employee security training, incident response plans, encryption for sensitive data, and vulnerability management. Missing these can increase premiums 50-100% or result in denial.
Can poor security disqualify me from cyber insurance?
Yes. Insurers now routinely deny coverage to organizations lacking basic security controls like MFA, email security, and backup systems. Even if approved, claims may be denied if you misrepresented your security posture on the application.
Do I need cyber insurance if I use cloud services?
Yes. Cloud providers like AWS and Azure have shared responsibility models. They secure the infrastructure, but you are responsible for securing your data and applications. Cloud provider terms of service typically limit their liability significantly.
Improve Your Security Posture
Our scanner identifies security gaps that increase your insurance premiums.
Start Free Scan