TL;DR
pnpm has a security advantage with strict dependency isolation by default. npm's flat node_modules allows packages to access undeclared dependencies. Both support lockfiles and audit commands for vulnerability scanning. pnpm's strictness prevents some supply chain attacks that exploit npm's hoisting. Choose pnpm for better default security; npm for maximum compatibility.
npm and pnpm both install JavaScript packages, but their approaches to node_modules structure differ significantly. pnpm's stricter isolation provides security benefits, while npm's flat structure prioritizes compatibility. Understanding these differences helps secure your vibe-coded applications against supply chain attacks.
Security Feature Comparison
| Security Feature | npm | pnpm |
|---|---|---|
| Dependency Isolation | Flat (hoisted) | Strict by default |
| Phantom Dependencies | Possible | Prevented |
| Lockfile | package-lock.json | pnpm-lock.yaml |
| Audit Command | npm audit | pnpm audit |
| Registry Support | Full | Full |
| Overrides | overrides field | overrides field |
| Script Isolation | No | Optional |
Dependency Isolation
npm's Flat Structure
npm hoists dependencies to the top level of node_modules, making all dependencies accessible to all packages. A package can require() dependencies it didn't declare. This "phantom dependency" problem can break builds when transitive dependencies change and allows supply chain attacks where malicious packages exploit undeclared dependencies.
pnpm's Strict Structure
pnpm uses a content-addressable store with symlinks. Each package can only access its declared dependencies. This prevents phantom dependencies and makes the dependency graph explicit. A malicious package can't access or override dependencies it wasn't given access to.
Supply Chain Security
Attack Vectors
Supply chain attacks exploit the trust placed in dependencies. Common vectors include:
- Typosquatting (similar package names)
- Dependency confusion (private/public name collision)
- Compromised maintainer accounts
- Malicious postinstall scripts
- Exploiting phantom dependencies
pnpm's Protections
pnpm's strict isolation prevents some of these attacks. A malicious package can't silently depend on a legitimate package that happens to be hoisted. The explicit dependency graph makes auditing easier. pnpm also supports restricting which packages can run postinstall scripts.
Choose npm When: You need maximum compatibility with existing projects or tools that assume npm's node_modules structure. npm is the default and works everywhere. Best for quick projects, tutorials, or when pnpm compatibility issues arise.
Choose pnpm When: You want better default security and faster installs. pnpm's strict isolation prevents phantom dependency issues. Best for production projects, monorepos, and security-conscious teams willing to address compatibility issues.
Lockfile Security
Lockfile Importance
Lockfiles ensure reproducible installs by pinning exact versions. Both npm and pnpm generate lockfiles that should be committed to version control. Without lockfiles, builds can silently use different dependency versions, potentially introducing vulnerabilities.
Integrity Checking
Both package managers verify package integrity using checksums in lockfiles. This prevents tampered packages from being installed. Ensure lockfile changes are reviewed in code review to catch suspicious dependency updates.
Best Practices
- Always commit lockfiles to version control
- Run npm/pnpm audit regularly and in CI
- Review lockfile changes in pull requests
- Use exact versions for critical dependencies
- Enable pnpm's strict mode to prevent phantom deps
- Consider restricting postinstall scripts
- Keep package managers and Node.js updated
Is pnpm more secure than npm?
pnpm's strict dependency isolation provides better default security by preventing phantom dependencies. Both support auditing and lockfiles. pnpm has a security edge, but both can be used securely with proper practices.
What about Yarn?
Yarn v1 (Classic) is similar to npm with hoisting. Yarn v2+ (Berry) with PnP provides strict isolation like pnpm. For security, both pnpm and Yarn Berry improve on npm's defaults. Choose based on your ecosystem and preferences.
Do I need both npm audit and pnpm audit?
Use the audit command for your chosen package manager. Both query the same vulnerability database. Running audit in CI and regularly during development catches known vulnerabilities in dependencies.
Scan Your Dependencies
CheckYourVibe provides deeper dependency analysis beyond npm/pnpm audit.
Try CheckYourVibe Free